Moral and Political Attitudes: Conviction, Neutrality and the Officer
Some attitudes are preferences. Others feel like truths about right and wrong. The second kind are stronger, harder to change and more dangerous in an officer who has not examined them.
Straight from the syllabus
Attitude: content, structure, function; its influence and relation with thought and behaviour; moral and political attitudes; social influence and persuasion.
Chapter 7 covered what an attitude is and Chapter 8 covered persuasion. This chapter covers the two named types the syllabus singles out.
Why the syllabus names these two
Every attitude has the three components from Chapter 7: affect (feeling), behaviour (tendency to act) and cognition (belief). The syllabus picks out moral and political attitudes because they are the two that most directly touch an officer’s use of power. A dislike of a cuisine affects nobody. A belief that a community is undeserving, or that a party is the enemy, can bend a decision on a ration card or a permission.
Moral attitudes: what makes them different
A moral attitude is an evaluation that the holder experiences as a matter of right and wrong, not of taste. “Child labour is wrong”, “caste discrimination is unjust” and “a bribe is a betrayal” are moral attitudes. Social psychologists, notably Linda Skitka’s work on moral conviction, have found that such attitudes behave differently from ordinary ones.
- Universal: the holder believes they apply to everyone, not just to himself.
- Objective-seeming: they feel like facts, so disagreement feels like error rather than difference.
- Emotionally charged: violation produces anger, disgust or guilt.
- Motivating: they push people to act, protest or blow the whistle even at personal cost.
- Resistant to authority: people will defy a superior, or even the law, when a moral conviction is at stake.
- Less tolerant: people keep more social distance from those who disagree on a moralised issue.
Those properties cut both ways. The same strength that makes Satyendra Dubey write to the Prime Minister about corruption in the Golden Quadrilateral project can, in an unexamined officer, become self-righteousness, refusal to listen and intolerance of legitimate difference.
Where moral attitudes come from
Family and early socialisation lay the base (Chapter 6). Religion and culture supply vocabulary such as dharma, seva and karma. Education widens or narrows them. Personal experience of injustice is often decisive; Ambedkar’s moral attitude to caste was formed by what he endured as a child. Kohlberg’s stages show that the same person can move from obeying rules for fear of punishment to acting on universal principles.
Political attitudes: content and structure
A political attitude is an evaluation of political objects: parties, leaders, ideologies, policies, institutions and groups. Its content usually sits along a few dimensions.
- Left and right: attitudes to equality, state intervention and markets.
- Liberal and conservative: attitudes to change, tradition and individual freedom.
- Authoritarian and democratic: attitudes to obedience, dissent and the rights of minorities. Adorno’s research on the authoritarian personality linked rigid obedience with hostility to out-groups.
- Eysenck’s two axes: radical versus conservative, and tough-minded versus tender-minded.
Political attitudes are formed through political socialisation: family, peers, school, media, caste and community networks and, increasingly, social media echo chambers that reward outrage and confirm what users already believe.
The civil servant’s problem
A civil servant is a citizen, so he will have political attitudes. The law does not ask him to have none. It asks him not to let them reach his work. Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and of the All India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968 bars membership of political parties, taking part in political movements and canvassing in elections. The duty is non-partisanship: serving whichever government the people elect with the same competence and candour.
Non-partisanship is not the same as having no values. An officer must be committed to the Constitution, to the rule of law and to the welfare of citizens, but neutral between parties. The debate over a “committed bureaucracy” in the 1970s showed what goes wrong when commitment is redirected from the Constitution to a party or leader.
How moral and political attitudes interact
The two often fuse. When a policy question, such as reservation, cow protection or land acquisition, becomes moralised, political opponents start to look not merely wrong but wicked. This is the engine of polarisation. For an officer the danger is specific: a moralised political attitude can make him feel justified in bending process for what he sees as a righteous cause.
Managing these attitudes in service
- Self-awareness: the first component of emotional intelligence (Chapter 9). Notice which groups or issues produce a strong reaction.
- Procedure as a shield: objective criteria, written reasons and recorded decisions limit how far bias can travel.
- Exposure: field postings, contact with people unlike oneself and Gandhi’s talisman widen moral attitudes.
- Constitutional morality: Ambedkar’s phrase for the habit of respecting constitutional forms even when one’s own side would gain by breaking them.
- Training and codes: LBSNAA modules on gender, caste and disability sensitisation target exactly these attitudes.
Where candidates lose marks
Defining attitude again. The question is about moral and political attitudes; spend one line on the general definition and move on.
Saying officers should have no political attitudes. They are citizens. The duty is non-partisanship in conduct, not emptiness.
Praising strong moral attitudes without the downside. Show both: courage to resist wrongdoing, and the risk of intolerance and self-righteousness.
Revision checklist
- Moral attitude: evaluation held as right or wrong, not as taste.
- Moral conviction is universal, objective-seeming, emotional, motivating, authority-resistant and less tolerant.
- Sources: family, religion and culture, education, personal experience; Kohlberg’s stages.
- Political attitude: evaluation of parties, leaders, ideologies, policies; left and right, liberal and conservative, authoritarian and democratic.
- Formed by political socialisation; social media echo chambers intensify them.
- Rule 5, CCS (Conduct) Rules 1964 and AIS (Conduct) Rules 1968: no party politics.
- Committed to the Constitution, neutral between parties; the “committed bureaucracy” debate.
- Manage through self-awareness, procedure, exposure, constitutional morality and training.
Practice questions
Distinguish between moral and political attitudes. How can a civil servant ensure that his political attitudes do not affect his official decisions? (10 marks, 150 words)
Approach: define both with one example each. Note that moral attitudes feel universal and objective while political attitudes concern parties, ideologies and policies, and that the two often fuse. Then give safeguards: conduct rules on political neutrality, objective criteria and written reasons, self-awareness, and commitment to the Constitution rather than to a party.
“Strong moral convictions are both an asset and a risk in public service.” Discuss. (10 marks, 150 words)
Approach: asset, with an example like Satyendra Dubey or S. R. Sankaran; risk, with self-righteousness, intolerance and bending process for a cause. Conclude with constitutional morality and emotional intelligence as the balance.
Comments are closed here on purpose, so that every question lands in one place where I actually reply. Drop yours under the latest ethics lecture and I will answer it there.




